Presented by Mr. R. E. B. Blanton in 1951. The Board of Trustees offered this trophy initially for annual competition in the Twenty foot and under Handicap Class, and adopted requirements for competition and perpetuation of the award identical to those prescribed in the deed of gift for the Henry E. Hutcheson, Jr. Memorial Trophy. In 1959, when the award class failed to have the required number of eligible yachts for two successive seasons, the award was changed by the Board to the Mobjack Class. In 1973, Laser became the award class. In 2023, the Trustees adopted the High Point scoring method to determine the recipient from skippers competing in FBYC events.
The Blanton Bowl shall be awarded to the ILCA skipper who is a member of Fishing Bay Yacht Club with the best score, as determined by the CBYRA High Point scoring formula, in Fishing Bay Yacht Club sponsored ILCA events open to all skippers. To be eligible, a yacht must be enrolled in the Club Register, in the current award class and must sail in at least 50% of the eligible events sponsored by Fishing Bay Yacht Club in which the class has a start, a single race having the standing of a regatta or of a Club series counts as such.
| 1951 | William C. Coleman | |
| 1952 | Herbert L. Potts | |
| 1959 | Roger Moorman | |
| 1960 | William B..Pierce | |
| 1961 | Roger Moorman | |
| 1962 | J. D. Winters & J. F. Newcomb | |
| 1963 | Not Awarded | |
| 1964 | William B. Pierce | |
| 1965 | James W. Enochs | |
| 1967 | Roger Moorman | |
| 1970 | James W. Enochs | |
| 1973 | Raymond J. Munsch | |
| 1974 | Raymond J. Munsch | |
| 1975 | Raymond J. Munsch | |
| 1976 | Raymond J. Munsch | |
| 1977 | Joseph L. Dennison Jr. | |
| 1978 | William E. Anderson | |
| 1979 | Not Awarded | |
| 1980 | Joseph Gander | |
| 1981 | Alain Vincey | |
| 1982 | Alain Vincey | |
| 1983 | Alain Vincey | |
| 1984 | Alain Vincey | |
| 1985 | Alain Vincey | |
| 1986 | Norwood "Trip" Davis | |
| 1987 | John D. Adair Jr. | |
| 1988 | Bob W. Walker | |
| 1989 | David R. Lee | |
| 1990 | Michael Miller | |
| 1991 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 1992 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 1993 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 1994 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 1995 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 1996 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 1997 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 1998 | David G. Porter | |
| 1999 | Anthony Kupersmith | |
| 2000 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 2001 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 2002 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 2003 | H. Bradshaw Squires | |
| 2004 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2005 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2006 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2007 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2008 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2009 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2010 | Not Awarded | |
| 2011 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2012 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2013 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2014 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2015 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2016 | Charles Brewer | |
| 2017 | Charles Brewer | |
| 2018 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2019 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2020 | Charles B. Drake III | |
| 2021 | Jonathan M. Deutsch | |
| 2022 | Reed McAllister | |
| 2023 | Jonathan M. Deutsch |